Home discussions products about writing Projects

Open Source for Collaborative Knowledge Development and Learning

Note: This site's content is accessible to all versions of every browser. However, this browser may not support basic Web standards, preventing the display of our site's design details. We support the mission of the Web Standards Project in the campaign encouraging users to upgrade their browsers.


Blog Entry [details and replies]

The Wales-Wide Web :: Graham Attwell on Learning, Knowledge and Technology Weblog 455 entries 26-October-2007 1 authors
show or hide details for this item Describing Learning Blog Entry 3 replies1 resource 04-January-2007 Graham Attwell
Kind:
Blog Entry
Created:
04-January-2007 19:26:29
Last Updated:
04-January-2007 19:42:35
Author:
Graham Attwell
Status:
visible

Resources and Links:

Dimensions of Faciltator Style Dimensions of Faciltator Style
This video looks at how we can classify and describe teaching or facilitator styles
Whilst the growing interest in informal learning is very welcome we need better ways of describing learning
Happy new year to you all.

I have spent a number of days over Christmas editing videos from the raw film of a workshop we ran in Germany last year as part of the European funded ASSIPA project. The workshop was on self evaluation and was heavily experiential in design.

It's not easy editing video of real teaching -  there are lots of interruptions and the like, and people coughing and sneezing in the background. On the other hand it is authentic and avoids the dangers of those horribly patronising 'now I'm going to teach you something' videos.

I will post a page somewhere giving access ot all the videos an to the learning materials - all of which is available under a Creative Commons License.

The video featured in this blog - "Dimensions of Facilitator Style - is based on the work of John Heron and James Kiltie from the Institute for the Development of Human Potential at University of Guildford, UK in 1970s. they came up with the following way of classifying teaching or facilitator styles:

Directive        --------------------------------------------    non-directive
(how things are done)

Structured        --------------------------------------------    unstructured
(what is done)

Cathartic        --------------------------------------------    non-cathartic
(extent to which facilitator takes emotional responsibility)

Catalytic        --------------------------------------------    non-catalytic
(extent to which facilitator manipulates the pace + pitch)

Interpretive    --------------------------------------------    non-interpretive
(extent to which facilitator is responsible for ‘sense making’)

Disclosing     --------------------------------------------    non-disclosing
(extent to which personal identity and values of facilitator are visible and affect the intervention)

Confronting    -------------------------------------------   non-confronting
(degree to which illegitimate values, meanings etc are made explicit)

(prescriptive    -------------------------------------------    descriptive)
(determining range of legitimate meanings)

Now, I think this is pretty cool and in another of the series of videos - http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-4423062597571110104 - we try using it in practice.

But what really interests me is the potential for describing learning. Because, welcome as the recent interest and focus on informal learning is - the division between formal and informal learning is just too crude and insensitive to help us greatly in understanding learning.  Over Christmas I started  working with Jenny Hughes - who is featured in the videos - on adopting the Dimensions of Facilitator Styles as a tool for  analysing learning. I'm meeting Jenny in Portugal next week and I hope we can find some time to take this work a little further.

I would welcoem anyones thoughts on this - and if you would like to know more about the videos or learning materails just drop me an email.




Comments please

If you are already registered here, please click the "Login" button to send your username/password with the comment. Click the "Anonymous/Join" button to leave a comment without logging in.

Please tell us who you are

E-Mail Address (Required)
We need a valid email address in order for you to post a comment. You will recieve an email containing a special validation link. The comment will not be published until validated
Name
Please leave your name
Join the site (optional)
If you would like to join the site while posting this comment, then choose a username.
Usernames must contain no spaces or special characters.
Title
Lead-in
Body Text ( HTML tags are allowed )
Validation
Please enter the text from the image above
Preview your comment


Describing Learning Discussion Topic 0 replies 18-November-2007 James Kilty
Kind:
Discussion Topic
Created:
18-November-2007 23:59:12
Last Updated:
19-November-2007 00:03:33
Author:
James Kilty
Graham Attwell describes a video about John Heron's work Six Dimensions of Facilitator Style.
I am resending my first comment which seems to have gone astray. Alas I cannot view the video and will attempt with a Windows computer (I use Linux). I am pleased to see that John's work is continuing, since the Human Potential Research Project/Group's workshop programme was closed. I must correct the attribution to me - I was the Director of the HPRP for a while and did run the Facilitator Styles course validated by the Institute for the Development of Human Potential which was a 2 year programme based on the model. It is quite a splendid model, comprehensive and flexible, accommodating a huge range of types of group. I used it myself and taught the model over many years, having also attended John's 2 year training, amongst others. I am currently updating my web pages at http://www.kilty.demon.co.uk/hprp.htm with a few pages on the model. I wish you all well in your efforts to apply it.
Describing Learning Discussion Topic 0 replies 18-November-2007 James Kilty
Kind:
Discussion Topic
Created:
18-November-2007 23:55:28
Last Updated:
Never Modified
Author:
James Kilty
Graham Attwell summariseses John Heron's Six Dimensions of Facilitaor Style
There seems to be a 7th added: Prescriptive-descriptive which seems to be a misunderstanding. I will be happy to correspond with anyone about the scheme.
teaching and learning interacting Discussion Topic 0 replies 05-January-2007 Joachim Wetterling
Kind:
Discussion Topic
Created:
05-January-2007 10:13:38
Last Updated:
Never Modified
Author:
Joachim Wetterling
I like the video and the dimensions, they actually are an interesting instrument to describe teaching. I wonder whether there are similar dimensions to describe learning. Maybe the same set can be used in a shaped way as in informal learning teaching and learning is somehow a joint activity anyway. An interesting chapter in this context is one about the activity theory and how learning settings can be considered activity systems for student centered learning (Jonassen, 2000, in Jonassen & Land, Theoretical foundations of learning environments, pp.89-121). I am still in the thinking process and would welcome a discussion about it but I might feel quite comfortable abut starting to see learning as a kind of activity system.