Home discussions products about writing Projects

Open Source for Collaborative Knowledge Development and Learning

Note: This site's content is accessible to all versions of every browser. However, this browser may not support basic Web standards, preventing the display of our site's design details. We support the mission of the Web Standards Project in the campaign encouraging users to upgrade their browsers.


Discussion Topic [details and replies]

The Wales-Wide Web :: Graham Attwell on Learning, Knowledge and Technology Weblog 455 entries 26-October-2007 1 authors
show or hide details for this item Interaction is a social process Discussion Topic 0 replies 17-November-2005 Andrea Kohlhase
Kind:
Discussion Topic
Created:
17-November-2005 09:31:10
Last Updated:
Never Modified
Author:
Andrea Kohlhase
Status:
visible
As interaction is a social process, you argued in your keynote-speech, interaction cannot take place between humans and computers. I disagree.
I do not disagree with the "truth" of the premise, I too believe that real interaction is a social process. But why can't there be a social relationship between user and medium and therefore real interaction? Here are THE characteristics of a social relationship according to a sociologist (Ellen Berscheid): ``At the hard core of the term is the notion that two entities are in a relationship to the extent that they have an {emph{impact}} on each other, or are {emph{interdependent}} with each other in that a change in the state of one causes a change in the state of the other''. So, the real question is: what does "social" mean, does it just concern living beings? Or does it mean that there is mutual trust (... not love ...), mutual respect (if it is a compatible relationship), mutual dependence? Actually, the current talk of "user-centered technology" and "eLearning2.0" (even idealiter) seems to me lop-sided: how can a relationship work if only one of the partners is taken as a partner, the other one as a machine which has to be controlled. The control for a learner over her learning scenario should not be confused with the control for a learner over the medium. I don't want cyborgs, but I do want a good business partner interaction (a SOCIAL interaction) with software. I would love to hear what others think about this.

Comments please

If you are already registered here, please click the "Login" button to send your username/password with the comment. Click the "Anonymous/Join" button to leave a comment without logging in.

Please tell us who you are

E-Mail Address (Required)
We need a valid email address in order for you to post a comment. You will recieve an email containing a special validation link. The comment will not be published until validated
Name
Please leave your name
Join the site (optional)
If you would like to join the site while posting this comment, then choose a username.
Usernames must contain no spaces or special characters.
Title
Lead-in
Body Text ( HTML tags are allowed )
Validation
Please enter the text from the image above
Preview your comment